Dockets
On February 2, 2017, the trial judge entered a written order denying the Appellant’s motion to recuse. The trial judge found that the Appellant’s motion to recuse was deficient because the motion was not supported by an affidavit or a declaration under penalty of perjury as required by Tennessee Supreme Court Rule 10B. The trial judge also found no basis for recusal and reiterated the findings made at the conclusion of the hearing.
. . . . We likewise conclude that the trial judge’s statements during the teleconference do not mandate recusal. The record reflects that the trial judge has encouraged settlement negotiations throughout the pendency of the case. The trial court’s statements were an effort to encourage the parties to continue to engage in settlement negotiations and do not demonstrate a predetermination of guilt. These statements do not demonstrate actual bias or create an appearance of bias requiring recusal.
For these reasons, the trial court’s denial of the Appellant’s motion to recuse is AFFIRMED. Accordingly, the request for a stay is denied. Because it appears that the Appellant is indigent, costs of the appeal are taxed to the State. . . . .
This matter came before the Court on the motion of the Appellant to stay trial court proceedings. The Appellant sought an Order from this Court staying proceedings while the Appellant’s appeal of his motion for recusal of the trial court judge is pending.
This Court has previously issued an opinion affirming the trial court’s denial of the motion to recuse filed by the Appellant. As such, it is hereby ORDERED that the motion to stay trial court proceedings pending appeal is moot.
This matter is before the Court upon the Petitioner Zachary Rye Adams’s second emergency application for extraordinary appeal pursuant to Rule 10 of the Tennessee Rules of Appellate Procedure. The Petitioner is seeking “immediate review and reversal of the trial court’s denial of his oral motion to continue trial.” . . . .
Tennessee Rules of Appellate Procedure 10(a) provides, “An extraordinary appeal may be sought on application and in the discretion of the appellate court alone of interlocutory orders of a lower court from which an appeal lies to the Supreme Court, Court of Appeals[,] or Court of Criminal Appeals. . . .” Extraordinary appeals are appropriate only “(1) if the lower court has so far departed from the accepted and usual course of judicial proceedings as to require immediate review, or (2) if necessary for complete determination of the action on appeal as otherwise provided in [the Rules of Appellate Procedure].” Tenn. R. App. P. 10(a). As explained in the Advisory Commission Comment to Rule 10, “[t]he circumstances in which review is available . . . .are very narrowly circumscribed to those situations in which the trial court or the intermediate appellate court has acted in an arbitrary fashion, or as may be necessary to permit complete appellate review on a later appeal.”
The Tennessee Supreme Court has stated:
An appellate court should grant a Rule 10 extraordinary appeal only when the challenged ruling represents a fundamental illegality, fails to proceed according to the essential requirements of the law, is tantamount to the denial of a party’s day in court, is without legal authority, is a plain or palpable abuse of discretion, or results in either party losing a right to interest that may never be recaptured.
Gilbert v. Wessels, 458 S.W.3d 895, 898 (Tenn. 2014) (citing State v. McKim, 215 S.W.3d 781, 791 (Tenn. 2007); State v. Willoughby, 594 S.W.2d 388, 392 (Tenn. 1980)). Appeals pursuant to Rule 10 “are reserved only for extraordinary departures from the accepted and usual course of judicial proceedings.” Id. (emphasis in original).
The granting or denial of a continuance is a matter left to the sole discretion of the trial court, whose decision will not be disturbed absent “a clear showing of gross abuse of this discretion to the prejudice of the defendant.” State v. Goodwin, 909 S.W.2d 35, 44 (Tenn. Crim. App. 1995) quoting Baxter v. State, 503 S.W.2d 226, 230 (Tenn.Crim.App.). Based upon the affidavit and evidence provided, this Petitioner has failed to show that the denial of the oral motion to continue by the trial court rises to the level of gross abuse of discretion. Furthermore, the guidance of the Supreme Court in regard to Rule 10 appeals would direct an even higher standard than the abuse of discretion standard set out in Goodwin and Baxter. We cannot conclude that the failure to grant a continuance would rise to that high level. The denial of the motion to continue does not create an “illegality” that would deny the Petitioner his day in court. The refusal to grant a continuance would be reviewable by this Court upon the appeal as of right by the Petitioner if he is later convicted. As such, the trial court has not denied him his day in court or deprived him of any rights or interests.
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the Petitioner’s application for extraordinary appeal is DENIED.
Zachary Rye Adams has satisfied this Court that he is financially indigent, unable to retain counsel for his appeal or pay for expert services. Adams does not waive his right to appellate counsel.
IT IS ORDERED that Jennifer Lynn Thompson, Esq. is hereby appointed to represent the Defendant for the purpose of Appeal.
. . . . On appeal, the Defendant contends that (1) the evidence is insufficient to support his convictions, (2) the trial court erred by denying a motion to recuse, (3) the trial court erred by granting the State’s motion to disqualify an attorney from the defense team, (4) the trial court erred by admitting evidence in violation of Tennessee Rule of Evidence 404(b), (5) the trial court erred by excluding a prior inconsistent statement, (6) the trial court erred by admitting hearsay evidence, (7) the trial court erred by excluding impeachment evidence, (8) the trial court erred by excluding “witness reactive conduct evidence,” (9) the trial court erred by failing to strike testimony from an undisclosed witness, and (10) the cumulative error doctrine entitles him to relief. We affirm the judgments of the trial court . . . .
Came the Defendant, Zachary Rye Adams, by counsel, and the State, by the Attorney General, and this cause was heard on the record on appeal from the Circuit Court for Hardin County; and upon consideration thereof, this court is of the opinion that no error exists in the judgments of the trial court.
It is, therefore, ordered and adjudged by this court that the judgments of the trial court are affirmed. The case is remanded to the Circuit Court for Hardin County for execution of the judgments and for collection of the costs accrued below.
It appearing that the Defendant is indigent, the costs of the appeal are taxed to the State of Tennessee.
Signed by Judges: Robert H. Montgomery, Jr., Timothy L. Easter, Jill B. Ayers.
Correspondence Received. Filed by Hardin County Circuit Court (Trial Court Clerk).
Douglas Thompson Bates IV, counsel for the Appellant, has filed a motion to withdraw the archived record in the above-captioned matter. Counsel asserts that the record is necessary to the preparation of the Appellant’s pending post-conviction proceeding. The motion is hereby GRANTED. The Clerk of this Court is directed to provide counsel with an electronic copy of the appellate record. Because it appears that the Appellant is indigent, costs associated with this motion shall be taxed to the State.
Correspondence Received. Filed by Hardin County Circuit Court (Trial Court Clerk).
This matter is before the Court upon motion of counsel for the State to withdraw the sealed items included in the archived record in the above-captioned appeal. Counsel states those items are needed for review during an upcoming hearing in the trial court regarding a pending motion the State has filed to enforce the prior orders of the trial court placing those items under seal. Said motion is hereby granted. The Clerk shall permit counsel to withdraw the record, including all sealed items, for a period of thirty days. No part of the original record shall be attached to a pleading, introduced as an exhibit, or otherwise used in a proceeding before any court. Moreover, counsel is not permitted to retain copies of any of the sealed items for his files. Counsel is directed to exercise extraordinary diligence to safeguard the record and to return it at the conclusion of the proceeding in the trial court in the same order and condition as it was when he received it. Costs associated with this order shall be taxed to the State.
COMES NOW, the parties, by and through Counsel, and agree to the following:
The Court finds that the following schedule of deadlines to file certain pleadings and schedule of hearing dates shall supersede all dates previously ordered or set:
All filings or other papers in this case should be filed with the Hardin County Circuit Court Clerk. In addition, all filings shall be forwarded to the Court via e-mail. No ex parte communications should be made absent exigent circumstances. All communications to the Court or staff should be shared with all parties. Scheduling conversations may be made with staff with all parties aware of the communications.
Comes now the parties, by and through Counsel, and agree to the following:
The Petitioner, Zachary Rye Adams, has filed a Notice to Strike Exhibits to his Amended Post Conviction Relief Petition. The State does not oppose such Notice. It is therefore ORDERED, DECREED and ADJUDGED:
. . . . For the reasons set forth herein, this Court does not find Petitioner has carried his burden to toll the statute of limitations in this matter. Accordingly, the State's motion to dismiss without an evidentiary hearing is GRANTED, and Petitioner Zachary Rye Adams' petition for writ of error coram nobis is hereby DISMISSED.
Petitioner moved to continue the evidentiary hearing in this post-conviction matter. For good cause shown, the motion is GRANTED.
The evidentiary hearing shall be continued from the original date of December 2, 2024, to January 13, 2025 @ 01:00 PM. The matter is anticipated to last five (5) days. All hearings will be held in the Circuit Court of Hardin County. Court sessions shall begin @ 08:30 AM unless otherwise specified herein, and continue each day until their conclusion. All filings or other papers in this case should be filed with the Hardin County Circuit Court Clerk. In addition, all filings shall be forwarded to the Court via e-mail.
No ex parte communications should be made absent exigent circumstances. All communications to the Court or staff should be shared with all parties. Scheduling conversations may be made with staff with all parties aware of the communications. The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to counsel.
This matter came before the Court on a motion to access sealed court records in the possession of the Clerk from Petitioner's technical record which might be relevant to the post-conviction proceedings. The parties agreed in open court that counsel for Petitioner would review the documents first to determine if they were relevant to the post-conviction proceedings. If relevant, a copy would be provided to both the State and Petitioner. The Court orally ordered the Clerk to allow access of the sealed files to Petitioner's counsel, Attorney Bates, and to reseal the documents immediately after they were reviewed and any necessary copies made.
This order is to memorialize the oral order of this Court given on December 2, 2024. Attorney Bates found no relevant documents to this proceeding! The Clerk is ORDERED TO RESEAL ALL PREVIOUSLY SEALED FILINGS referred to above and to maintain those sealed files.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to counsel.
A Hardin County Jury convicted Zachary Rye Adams in 2017 of first-degree premeditated murder; two counts of first-degree felony murder; two counts of especially aggravated kidnapping, a Class A felony and three counts of aggravated rape, a Class A felony. The Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the convictions in 2022, and the defendant has filed a post-conviction petition in Hardin County alleging ineffective assistance of counsel.
The Court of Criminal Appeals still possesses some of the trial exhibits, motion exhibits and other evidence submitted as the appellate record in this case. This Court and both the State of Tennessee and the petitioner need to access the appellate record, including both the sealed and unsealed portions thereof, in preparation for this hearing as well as for the hearing.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the Circuit Court Clerk of Hardin County, and/or his or her designee be allowed to obtain from the Court of Criminal Appeals the appellate record in the above-referenced matter, including all evidence and exhibits currently in the possession of the Court of Criminal Appeals; the Circuit Court Clerk of Hardin County, and/or his or her designee shall be allowed to transport said record, including any evidence and exhibits to Hardin County and maintain said file and evidence and exhibits in the Hardin County Clerk's office for the duration of these post-conviction proceedings.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to counsel.
The Court, sua sponte, determined that additional time is necessary for the parties to adequately review the voluminous discovery and properly prepare for the evidentiary hearing. The following schedule shall control and supersede any prior schedule:
All hearings will be held in the Circuit Court of Hardin County. Court sessions shall begin @ 08:30 AM unless otherwise specified herein, and continue each day until their conclusion. All filings or other papers in this case should be filed with the Hardin County Circuit Court Clerk. In addition, all filings shall be forwarded to the Court via e-mail. No ex parte communications should be made absent exigent circumstances. All communications to the Court or staff should be shared with all parties. Scheduling conversations may be made with staff with all parties aware of the communications.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to counsel.
This matter came before the Court on January 16, 2025, for a hearing on the State's Motion to Dismiss Post-Conviction Claims and the State's Motion to Inspect All Documents and Exhibits Filed Under Seal Prior to the Post-Conviction Filing. At the hearing, the Petitioner indicated no opposition to the State's Motion to Inspect All Documents and Exhibits Filed Under Seal Prior to the Post-Conviction Filing. Accordingly, this Court orally GRANTED the State's motion and directed the State to prepare a separate order for the Court on this motion.
During the hearing, the parties presented arguments related to the State's Motion to Dismiss Post-Conviction Claims. Both in his response and argument, the Petitioner conceded paragraph 36 of the Second Amended Petition was a writ of error coram nobis claim not available for post-conviction relief in these proceedings. Accordingly, the State's Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED IN PART without objection as to paragraph 36 of the Second Amended Petition.
The remainder of the State's Motion to Dismiss Post-Conviction Claims, however, contains substantive claims mixed with either claims of ineffective assistance of counsel and/or state misconduct. Accordingly, this Court will take the remainder of the State's Motion to Dismiss UNDER ADVISEMENT until after the evidentiary hearings in this matter.
Also at the hearing, the Petitioner's counsel clarified that the Second Amended Petition superseded the (First) Amended Petition, but it did not supersede the Pro Se Petition originally filed. Accordingly, this Court orally ordered the State to file an answer to the issues raised in the Pro Se Petition and the Second Amended Petition within thirty days of the hearing. However, thirty days from the hearing date falls on a Saturday; therefore, the State is ORDERED to file its answer by February 18, 2025.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to all counsel of record.
This matter came to be heard upon the Petitioner, ZACHARY RYE ADAMS' request for a Writ of Habeas Corpus ad Testificandum, pursuant to his Petition for Post Conviction Relief. Pursuant to T.C.A. §41-21-305 and 28 C.F.R. §527.31 (2025), this Court finds the Petitioner's request well taken and finds and Orders as follows:
This matter came before the Court on February 14, 2025, for a Zoom hearing on the State's Motion for Pretrial Production of Documents and Objects and the Petitioner's limited objection to the motion.
The parties agreed the subpoenas to Petitioner's trial attorneys were only for information not previously provided to Attorney Bates. Any issue raised by Petitioner's current counsel related to persons other than Petitioner's trial counsel was agreed to be premature at this time.
After hearing from the parties, the Court instructed the State to draft the subpoenas requested with a compliance deadline of March 7, 2025. In addition, the State was instructed to draft orders with the Court's stated limitations related to the waiver of attorney client privilege by Petitioner's trial counsel, Ms. Thompson, Mr. Simmons, and Mr. Gonzales. Also, this Court set a Zoom hearing for March 7, 2025 @ 01:30 PM CST. The parties subject to the subpoenas for pretrial production of documents and objects shall appear at the March 7, 2025, hearing via Zoom as well.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to all counsel of record.
The trial court sealed certain pleadings and ordered that certain information not be mentioned at trial. The State seeks to have this Court review certain sealed pleadings and information in camera and order that the pleadings and related information remain sealed in these proceedings.
The Court will conduct a sealed hearing on the State's motion on March 18, 2025. All further pleadings on these issues shall be filed under seal pending further orders of the Court.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to all counsel of record.
On February 26th, 2025, the Petitioner's attorney Douglas Bates IV filed a motion to allow him to meet with his client over zoom. The Court finds that the motion is well taken to the extent that either or both Crystal Etue and/or Douglas Bates IV may meet with Mr. Zachary Rye Adams. It is therefore ORDERED, DECREED and ADJUDGED:
This matter came to be heard on November 26, 2024, before the Honorable J. Brent Bradberry, Judge for the Circuit Court for Hardin County, Tennessee upon the State of Tennessee's Motion to Deem Attorney-Client Privilege Waived for Post Conviction Relief Issues. Counsel for both parties were present in Court. Based upon the statements and arguments of counsel, along with the entire record, the Court finds as follows:
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the State of Tennessee's Motion to Deem Attorney-Client Privilege Waived for Post Conviction Relief Issues as to JERRY GONZALEZ is GRANTED IN PART as to the issues raised by Petitioner Adams in his post-conviction petition, alleging that his trial attorneys' representation was ineffective.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to counsel.
The Court previously set March 18, 2025, to hear motions. Based on conflicts with certain attorneys involved in the matter, the Court finds it is appropriate to continue this hearing date to March 21, 2025. Hearings on all matters ripe for decision will commence @ 09:00 AM in the Circuit Courtroom of Hardin County, Tennessee.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to counsel.
This matter came before the Court on March 21, 2025, for a hearing on various motions filed by the parties, including several motions related to Petitioner's co-defendant, Jason Autry. Based upon the pleadings and information already in the record on Jason Autry's potential testimony in this proceeding, this Court finds there are certain issues related to Mr. Autry's constitutional rights and his attorney/client privilege [1], as well as potential consequences should Mr. Autry choose to testify.
Therefore, this Court concludes it is necessary to appoint counsel to Mr. Autry for the limited purpose of advising Mr. Autry concerning these rights and potential consequences. Accordingly, this Court hereby APPOINTS attorney Ben Harmon as counsel for Jason Autry for this limited purpose.
Attorney Harmon shall contact Jason Autry and advise him in accordance with this order. Following this meeting, Attorney Harmon shall file a notice with this Court by April 11, 2025, advising this Court concerning Mr. Autry's decisions concerning both any potential testimony and/or any waiver of his attorney/client privilege.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to all counsel of record, including Attorney Ben Harmon.
[1] Petitioner has sought subpoenas for Mr. Autry's trial attorneys, Michael Scholl and Michael Flanagan, as well as his investigator, Clark Chapman.
This matter came before the Court on March 21, 2025, for a hearing on various motions filed by the parties. At the hearing, this Court made the following rulings based upon the record, the applicable law, and arguments of counsel:
This matter is set for a Zoom status hearing on April 25, 2025 @ 09:00 AM CST. The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to all counsel of record.
This matter came before the Court on March 21, 2025, for a hearing on various motions filed by the parties, including Petitioner's motion to issue a writ of appearance for inmate John Dylan Adams. As of the hearing date, neither the State nor counsel for co-defendant John Dylan Adams had filed a response to the Motion. In addition, counsel for John Dylan Adams was not present.
Accordingly, this Court found this issue was not ripe for disposition. Counsel for John Dylan Adams shall file any opposition to this motion by April 11, 2025.
The Clerk shall file this order and provide a filed copy to all counsel of record, including counsel for John Dylan Adams.
This matter came before the court on 21 March 2025 upon the motion of Dana Crosland McLendon III to withdraw and to substitute Cayley Turrin as counsel for Dr. Katie Spirko. Present before the court were all counsel of record and Zach Adams. In opposition to this motion, the State had filed a Motion to Clarify the Record. The court heard the statements of Mr. McLendon and Mrs. Weirich, for the State. After reviewing the motion and the declaration filed by Mr. McLendon, the court finds the motion to have merit.
Mr. McLendon's motion to withdraw and substitute Cayley Turrin as counsel for Dr. Katie Spirko is GRANTED. Mr. McLendon is relieved as counsel for Dr. Spirko. Cayley Turrin is recorded as counsel for Dr. Spirko.
The States's Motion to Clarify the Record is DENIED as moot.
It appearing to the Court that John Dylan Adams is required in the Circuit Court for Hardin County, Tennessee on May 20th, 2025 @ 09:00 AM.
You are hereby authorized, ordered and directed to deliver the body of JOHN DYLAN ADAMS to the Hardin County Courthouse in Savannah, Tennessee, on the 20th day of May, 2025 @ 09:00 AM from his place of confinement at the Riverbend Maximum Security Institution located at 7475 Cockrill Bend Blvd., Nashville, Tennessee 37209, for said court appearance until such time as his presence is no longer required and thereafter return him to Riverbend Maximum Security Institution at the aforementioned address.
Before the Court is a motion in limine filed by the State on May 15, 2025, to exclude from evidence at Mr. Adams' post-conviction hearing a video-recorded interview dated December 22, 2023, between codefendant Jason Autry and Dr. Katie Spirko, a neuropsychologist hired by counsel for Mr. Adams. During the interview, Jason Autry claims his September 2017 trial testimony was false. In a response filed on May 17, 2025, the Petitioner argued that Mr. Autry's statement is admissible as a declaration against interest from an unavailable witness under Tenn. R. Evid., Rule 804(3) . . . .
. . . . WHEREFORE, the motion to exclude Jason Autry's video interview recorded on December 22, 2023, is GRANTED.
Before the Court is the Petitioner's oral request for an order granting him an interlocutory appeal under Rule 9 of the Tennessee Rules of Appellate Procedure. On May 19, 2025, this Court heard argument on the State's Motion in Limine #1 to exclude a video recorded interview of codefendant Jason Autry dated December 22, 2023, wherein Mr. Autry says his trial testimony was false. The Petitioner asserts he intended to use the statement, not only as substantive evidence, but also in the examination of various witnesses. This Court granted the State's motion by an oral ruling from the bench and subsequent written order filed May 22, 2025. This Court finds that an interlocutory appeal is appropriate for the reasons set forth below . . . .
. . . . WHEREFORE, it is Ordered, Adjudged, and Decreed, in accordance with Rule 9 of the Tennessee Rules of Appellate Procedure, that the Petitioner, Zachary Rye Adams, is granted leave to act as the Appellant and to appeal the Court's Order of May 22, 2025, excluding Mr. Autry's statement. The following legal issue is certified as appropriate for such an appeal:
Whether this Court erred in excluding from evidence co-defendant Jason Autry's video-recorded interview, dated December 22, 2023.
Appellant Adams shall file the appropriate application in the Court of Criminal Appeals to perfect this interlocutory appeal. Appellant Adams is directed to notify the Court as soon as possible of the final disposition of appellate proceedings concerning this Court's evidentiary Order.
The Clerk of Court shall prepare the record on appeal in accordance with the attached.
A hearing on the merits of the Petitioner's request for post-conviction relief commenced on May 19, 2025. At the end of the day on May 23, 2025, the Court recessed the proceedings. Upon the agreement of the parties, the following dates are scheduled for a continuation of the proof in this case, beginning each day @ 08:30 AM: August 14–15, 2025; November 19–21, 2025; December 29–30, 2025; January 7–8, 2025.
The deadline to complete depositions of witnesses authorized by law to offer testimony by deposition shall be ninety (90) days after a ruling from the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals on the Petitioner's Rule 9 appeal.
All prospective witnesses remain under this Court's instruction not to communicate with anyone about this case or receive any information about it.
Before the Court is a request by the Petitioner to amend his post-conviction petition and a proposed addition to his petition containing allegations related to an ATM video from Community South Bank in Parsons, dated April 13, 2011 @ 11:12 AM. This Court granted the motion from the bench on May 19, 2025. The rules of post-conviction procedure allow liberal amendments to a post-conviction petition. See (Tenn. S. Ct. R. 28). This Court finds it appropriate to grant the motion to amend, and the "proposed addition" will be considered on the merits with the Petitioner's pro se, second amended, and supplemental petitions for post-conviction relief.
WHEREFORE, the Petitioner's motion to amend is GRANTED.
Before the Court are two motions in limine filed by the state on May 15, 2025. This Court addressed the motions from the bench on May 19, 2025.
Motion in limine # 2 seeks to exclude from the evidentiary hearing evidence not provided as reciprocal discovery under Rule 16. Counsel for the Petitioner stated that reciprocal discovery had been disclosed in full, with a possible exception for a developing matter. See Petitioner's Response to Motion in Limine 1-3, filed May 19, 2025. This Court determined that it would address the admissibility of subsequently arising or undisclosed facts, if any, at the time they occur.
Motion in limine # 3 seeks to exclude from the evidentiary hearing any evidence and testimony regarding polygraph and voice stress testing and results. Counsel for the Petitioner stated such evidence would not be introduced during the hearing. See Petitioner's Response to Motion in Limine 1-3, filed May 19, 2025: Accordingly, this motion is uncontested.
WHEREFORE, this Court RESERVES RULING on the state's motion in limine # 2 and GRANTS the state's motion in limine #3.
This matter is before the Court for adjudication of Petitioner's post-conviction claims after a full evidentiary hearing. For the reasons set forth, post-conviction relief is DENIED . . . .
The Appellate Court Clerk's Office has entered the above action.
Pursuant to TRAP 9(d), any other party may file an answer in opposition within 10 days after filing of the application. Please use the appeal number listed above on all future filings.
/s/ James M. Hivner, Clerk of the Appellate Courts
This matter is before the Court upon the Petitioner's application for an interlocutory appeal pursuant to Tennessee Rule of Appellate Procedure 9. In his application, the Petitioner asserts that the post-conviction court held a hearing on the State's motion to exclude the video-recorded statement of codefendant Jason Autry on May 19, 2025. The Petitioner asserts that at the conclusion of this hearing, he "orally requested this Rule 9 application" and that the trial court made a ruling from the bench on May 20, 2025 [1]. The Petitioner asserts in his application that he has not yet received the transcripts from these two court dates.
Although the State notes in its response that a party seeking an interlocutory appeal "must file and serve a motion requesting such relief," Tenn. R. App. P. 9(b), the State does not argue that the Petitioner's application should be denied due to procedural default. Accordingly, this Court hereby ORDERS the Petitioner to file a supplemental application within twenty (20) days of the date of this order containing the relevant transcripts.
This matter is before the Court upon the application of the Petitioner, Zachary Rye Adams, for an interlocutory appeal pursuant to Tennessee Rule of Appellate Procedure 9. The Defendant seeks to challenge the post-conviction court's order granting the State's motion in limine to exclude a recorded post-trial statement of his codefendant, Jason Autry. The Petitioner argued that the trial court erroneously determined that the statement did not satisfy the statement against interest exception to the hearsay rule. See Tenn. R. Evid. 804(b)(3). The State has filed a response in opposition to the motion. Based on the following, we deny the Petitioner's motion for an interlocutory appeal.
Judges Signed: Matthew J. Wilson, Camille R. McMullen, J. Ross Dyer, Judge.
The Appellant, Zachary Rye Adams, is appealing the denial of his post-conviction petition. He filed notice of appeal on July 22, 2026. The record has not been filed, but the deadline for doing so has not yet expired. Tenn. R. App. P. 24 and 25.
Currently before the Court is the State’s motion for a limited remand to the trial court so it may “seek a protective order” for “certain information [previously ordered by the trial court] to be sealed or confidential.” In its motion, the State alleges “a third party – who gained access to the unredacted discovery while employed as the appellant’s agent – is posting sealed and confidential information on social media and disseminating it via a podcast.” The Appellant opposes. Counsel for the Appellant asserts “[r]emand is unnecessary because the orders the State needs already exist.” Furthermore, counsel insists they are not responsible for the action of a non-party and that they will continue to abide by the directives of the trial court’s protective orders and the Rules of Professional Conduct.
Generally, and as both parties recognize, the jurisdiction of this Court attaches to the case after notice of appeal is filed. See State v. Peele, 58 S.W.3d 701, 705 (Tenn. 2001). However, this Court has the authority to remand matters to the trial court for consideration in certain situations. See, e.g., Tenn. R. App. P. 18, Advisory Commission Comment [2006] (appellate court not precluded from remanding matter to trial court for indigency determination); Tenn. R. App. P. 24(e) (“Any differences regarding whether the record accurately discloses what occurred in the trial court shall be submitted to and settled by the trial court regardless of whether the record has been transmitted to the appellate court.”); Boutrous v. State, No. M2025-01076-CCA-R3-PC, 2026 WL 1804180 (Tenn. Crim. App. June 23, 2026) (Order, Sep. 11, 2025) (remanding matter to trial court for waiver of counsel determination).
That being said, and despite the fact that notice of appeal is on file from the final order in this post-conviction matter, the trial court has not lost the authority to address concerns regarding any prior order it entered regarding the confidentiality of filings in this post-conviction matter. Thus, a remand, or a stay of proceedings on appeal, is not necessary. The State’s motion is, therefore, denied as moot. This appeal shall now continue in accordance with the Rules of Appellate Procedure. Any subsequent order entered by the trial court on the issue of confidentiality of filings in this case may be included in the appellate record, if necessary.
This matter is before the Court upon the Appellant’s motion for additional time to file the transcript of evidence. The Appellant filed notice of appeal on July 22, 2026, but he did not file the instant motion until October 20, 2026. Tenn. R. App. P. 24(b) (transcript due sixty days after notice of appeal filed). The Appellant is requesting until January 19, 2027, to file the complete transcript with the trial court clerk. He indicates the State is unopposed to a thirty-day extension at this time. And although the Appellant suggests the requested extension is at the behest of the court reporters, he failed to attach to his motion their affidavits attesting to the reasons for that request. Tenn. Ct. Crim. App. R. 8, Comments.
The Court recognizes the extent of the proceedings conducted in this post-conviction matter. The Appellant states a portion of those proceedings have already been transcribed. Upon review, the Court hereby grants the requested extension, in part. Accordingly, the Appellant shall now have until December 18, 2026, to file the complete transcript with the trial court clerk. Thereafter, this matter shall continue to proceed in accordance with the Rules of Appellate Procedure. Tenn. R. App. P. 24 and 25 (record due on appeal forty-five days after transcript filed). Should the Appellant require additional time beyond this deadline, he shall include in his motion the affidavits of the reporters attesting to the reason(s) for the request.
Explore the evidence in the case against Zach Adams.
All the filings I have as of now.